Menu

Added to Cart

You have no items in your shopping cart.


The dynamic duo you'll use again and again.
Few pieces of kitchen gear improve after years of heavy use. In fact, we could think of only one: the cast-iron pan. As you cook in it, a cast-iron pan gradually takes on a slick natural patina that releases food easily. Well-seasoned cast iron can rival, and certainly outlast, a nonstick pan; it’s virtually indestructible and easily restored if mistreated. Cast iron’s special talent is heat retention, which makes it ideal for browning, searing, and shallow frying. Our longtime favorite wins test after test, and the tempered glass lid from the same manufacturer traps the heat, fits snugly, and lets you see what’s happening as you cook.

Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

WINNER - HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

GOOD ★★★   FAIR ★★   POOR ★

BROWNING  ★★★

DURABILITY  ★★★

STICKING  ★★★

EASE OF USE  ★★★

Reviewed in Cook's Illustrated May 2015
Our old winner arrived with the slickest preseasoned interior and only got better. Broad enough to cook two big steaks, it browned foods deeply, and its thorough seasoning ensured that our acidic pan sauce picked up no off-flavors. Though its handle is short, the pan has a helper handle that made lifting easy. It survived abuse testing without a scratch. An excellent pan, at an excellent price, that you’ll never have to replace.

Diameter: 12"     Depth: 2.25"     Weight: 7lbs, 10⅛oz     Handle: 4.75"     Cooking Surface Diameter: 10"   
Pre-Seasoned & Ready to Use?: Yes
    Helper Handle?: Yes    Pouring Lips: 2



Lodge 12-Inch Tempered Glass Lid

WINNER - RECOMMENDED

GOOD ★★★   FAIR ★★   POOR ★

FIT  ★★½

EASE OF USE  ★★★

PERFORMANCE  ★★½

CLEANUP  ★★★

MAINTENANCE  ★★★

Reviewed in Cook's Illustrated March 2016
This lightweight lid helped produce nicely browned onions and evenly cooked eggs, and it was much easier to lift and clean than the heavy cast-iron lid. It contained moisture and messes, and its glass material allowed users to get a good sense of how their food was cooking.

Diameter: 12"     Weight: 1.8lbs     Dishwasher Safe?: yes     Oven Safe?: Yes, to 400°F


Book-Cover

  SPECIAL OFFER WITH TODAY'S DEAL  

SAVE 40%

One-Pan Wonders

138 Fuss-Free Meals for Your Sheet Pan, Dutch Oven, Skillet, Roasting Pan, Casserole, and Slow Cooker.


$27.95 $16.99

Want to add this book?
Select from the drop down above.

How we tested cast-iron pans

We tested both traditional and enameled cast-iron pans (the latter have a coating of enamel over the cast iron). We scrambled eggs, seared steaks, made a tomato-caper pan sauce (to check if its acidity reacted with the pan surface), skillet-roasted thick fish fillets that went from stove to oven, baked cornbread, and shallow-fried breaded chicken cutlets. At the end of testing, we scrambled more eggs to see whether the pans’ surfaces had evolved. To simulate years of kitchen use, we plunged hot pans into ice water, banged a metal spoon on their rims, cut in them with a chef’s knife, and scraped them with a metal spoon.


Winning traits of the Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet:

More reliably nonstick than enameled cast-iron pans

Virtually indestructible

Didn't chip of scratch

Easy to clean


Cast Iron Skillet and Lid Image
Cast Iron Skillet and Lid Image

How we tested cast-iron skillet lids

We purchased two dedicated cast-iron skillet lids from Lodge, one made of cast iron and one made of tempered glass. We used them to cover skillets filled with frying eggs and caramelizing onions, evaluating how thoroughly they retained heat and dispersed condensation and thus how evenly and thoroughly the foods cooked. Then we assessed how well they contained messes, covering skillets full of simmering tomato sauce and observing the extent to which the stove and counter got spattered. Finally, we looked at how easy the lids were to clean, washing each by hand. As per Lodge’s recommendation, we also dried and oiled the cast-iron lid after every use.


Winning traits of the Lodge 12-Inch Tempered Glass Lid:

Lightweight at just under 2 pounds

Its phenolic plastic handle stays cool

Requires no maitenance

Was a breeze to clean

Offered the best visability

Ovensafe to 400°F






X
How We Use Your Email Address

America's Test Kitchen will not sell, rent, or disclose your email address to third parties unless otherwise notified. Your email address is required to identify you for free access to content on the site. You will also receive free newsletters and notification of America's Test Kitchen specials.